Well for me, I researched all the information on both procedures. At first I wanted the band cos its a less evasive operation but there is always the danger of slipping back into old habits. In fact my consultant said he knew of people who liquidised chocolate to feed their cravings! In th end I went for the bypass (and the consultant agreed) cos of my eating habits. I love sweet and high fat stuff and if I'm putting myself through this major operation, it has to be for keeps, no chance at all of slipping back into old ways. Mind you, the thought of such a big operation makes me feel sick anyway!!!! Julie x