hi, am in a similar situation, banded in 2006, privately. lost 7 stone, then started to have severe vomiting, reflux, choking at night, pouch wasnt emptying, and finally closed up causing dehydration.removed private again 2010, gained 6 stone back now awaiting bypass at heartlands, sounds like you are in with a big chance, they know it doesnt work for everyone, did you lose any weight - i was told by surgeon no need to prove weight management as it was obvious i could live with the disciplines involved. i have lost 5% since then, and still have to do pre-op when the time comes, but all hospitals different. good luck.