I've read this thread with interest....
Psychologically, I wonder what the best approach for the patient is?
From a patients perspective - I went from initial enquiry to surgery 8 months, via the NHS route.
Personally, I believe that the longer I'd waited, the less likely I'd be to actually have surgery. Certain people would have tried to talk me out of it - peer pressure and friends and family I suppose. I guess if I was still pre-op now, I'd be in a 50/50 shall I, shan't I do it situation.
I guess it's all down to mental resolve, willpower, willingness to wait (I can be quite impatient!) and whatever other factors may be influencing your life.
CaniSani, don't give up just yet. You've come a long way. We'll all gone down the 'traditional' weight loss route. If we could maintain that, then none of us would need surgery. It's a tool to help us lose weight, some of us need it.
You'll ultimately decide what's best for you. Wishing you all the best, whatever you finally choose. x